COMING OUT HOT! Recipe: St. Louis Style Pizza

Posted: July 20, 2010 in Pizza, Pizza, Recipes
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

I recently came across Provel cheese in the special cheeses section at Dillons. When I first saw it I couldn’t place what I wanted it for, but bought it anyway because I knew at one point I wanted it. I ate it on salads, and even melted it on nachos (don’t judge, I love chips and cheese and was eating homemade salsa). Anyway, then it hit me: ST. LOUIS PIZZA! Everything I read about St. Louis pizza said you HAD to use Provel cheese. And even though I could make my own, I never wanted to take that last step to mix my own cheese. I’m not sure why? The recipe (included) is actually pretty simple.

Melty. Cheesy. Yummy.

The crust for St. Louis pizza is thin and crispy, which means the crust doesn’t have to rise. Yippee! Not that I mind letting a crust rise, but it definitely makes for a quick dinner.

1 cup all-purpose flour
3/8 cup water (my measuring cup did’t go in 1/8ths so I ended up doing a little more than 2/3rds a cup)
1/8 tsp instant dry yeast (this is just enough to make the crust light & crispy without it rising)
1 tbsp oil
1/2 tsp salt

First, I activated my yeast (if you have instant, you don’t have to do this), which means I used a little tiny bit of sugar. Then I mixed the activated yeast with the rest of the water. After that, add half the flour and salt and mixed. Then add the oil. Then the remaining flour. You could use a stand mixer, but trust me, this was easy to mix. Then I threw it on the counter and kneaded it a little.

Don’t let the dough rise. In fact, if you do it will compromise the outcome of the crust.

Spread the dough thin, to about 12 inches in diameter.  I used a rolling pin and my hands to stretch. Then it says to place on a pizza stone and bake at 450 degrees. I wasn’t sure if you were actually supposed to bake the crust PRIOR to adding toppings (and then bake again). But I think you are. I’m not sure how long to bake because it doesn’t say. But I would say bake it until the crust becomes light golden brown. It also doesn’t say whether to pre-heat the stone, but I always pre-heat mine when I pre-head the oven. Anyway, I DIDN’T pre-cook my crust, but next time I will because I had a hard time getting the crust to cook without burning my toppings.

1/4th of a 16 oz can of diced tomatoes
1/4th of a 6 oz can of tomato paste
1 1/8 tsp sugar
1/4 tsp crushed basil
1/8 tsp salt
1/16 tsp thyme (or just shake in some Italian seasoning)

This makes enough sauce for one pizza. But you could easily multiply it by 4 to use the entire can of diced tomatoes and tomato paste. I’m sure you could freeze this sauce, but that’s not really my style. In fact, I’m not sure I have a style? All you do is mix these ingredients together. I ended up blending them in a food processor to make a smoother sauce, but you can do chunky, too.

If you want to create your own Provel (as I said above, I bought mine):

1/2 cup shredded white cheddar cheese
1/4 cup shredded Swiss cheese
1/4 cup shredded provolone cheese
1/2 tsp liquid hickory smoke flavoring

Toss until cheeses and smoke flavoring are completely incorporated.

Toppings the Pizza
I don’t know why but the recipe I found listed “typical” St. Louis pizza toppings. I say use whatever you want. But for the sake of being typical, here are suggestions: Extra-Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Sausage, Hamburger, Pepperoni, Anchovy, Bacon, Black Olive, Mushroom, Canadian Bacon, Jalapenos, Pineapple, Banana Peppers, and Tomatoes.

After you’ve cooked the plain crust to a light golden brown, add the sauce then your toppings of choice, and sprinkle with cheese. Then top with oregano, basil and thyme. Or if you’re me, sprinkle with more Italian seasonings. Put back in a 450 degree oven and cook until the cheese is slightly golden brown (mine overcooked because I didn’t precook my crust), and the bottom of the crust is dark golden brown.

Even though my crust was under-baked it was still good, but I definitely over-baked the toppings to get it to where it was close. The toppings didn’t taste bad, just a little mushy. So that’s why I say I’d pre-cook the crust next time. And the true test was I actually liked the cold/leftover pizza. Which rarely happens with other crusts I’ve used!

Oh, and for true St. Louis pizza, cut into squares. And enjoy!

Sauce ingredients, ready to be mixed with the food processor.

I only used black olives, green peppers, onions and tomatoes because I didn’t want to get out in the heat and buy meat. Trust me, I was craving Italian sausage, pepperoni or ground beef, though. Next time, meat is a MUST!

I mixed the salt and flour by hand, then stirred in the water/yeast mixture.

Then you stir in the oil, and add the last cup of flour.

Here is the sauced pizza, covered with toppings.

My Provel cheese came in ropes, but it melted up fine. If you make the cheese by hand it’ll probably be shredded. You can probably also buy shredded Provel. You also can’t probably see, but I’ve added a shake of Italian seasonings on top of the toppings.

Here’s my pizza fresh out of the oven. YUM! The toppings are a little more done than I’d like. But I had a hard time getting the crust done. This is why I assume I needed to pre-bake the crust.

Still looks delicious, no? It was!

  1. Kendra says:

    Mmmmm. Sure does look delicious. The crust seems super easy, I’m totally trying this next time I make pizza. But, I’ll be sure to add meat to mine.

  2. Lynds says:

    Oh my gosh that looks sooooo yum!

    • Kelly says:

      I can’t wait to try it again, pre-cooking the crust. The sauce was really good. If you like sweeter sauces, it was really easy to make. And Kendra’s right, the crust is super-easy, especially compared to rising crusts. So overall, a win.

      And I was surprised I liked Provel cheese so much.

  3. […] We were a split decision on the pizza. I actually liked the crust. It reminded me of the way St. Louis style pizza crust is supposed to taste. But Karla didn’t like it. She compared it to a cracker. So if […]

  4. […] We were a split decision on the pizza. I actually liked the crust. It reminded me of the way St. Louis style pizza crust is supposed to taste. But Karla didn’t like it. She compared it to a cracker. So if […]

  5. […] they first made a recipe for St. Louis pizza, which I have made before. And I liked, even though I didn’t give myself much chance to perfect it. So when they […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s